Why We Love It: Beautifully blendable, with tons of color payoff and nary a crease in sight, this product wowed us in every category. Our tester could easily blend the pigment using the stick ...

jane iredale’s ColorLuxe Eye Shadow Sticks are on sale for 50% off in all 10 of the highly-pigmented, cream-to-powder matte ...

Or rather, they were—until I tried the Almay Color & Care Tint Stick. Shop Now As the name suggests, it’s a multitasking, cream color stick meant for both cheeks and lips. It comes in five ...